Talktheroo wrote:Diesels will always be noisy.
Petrol engines will always be more expensive to run, as far as fuel goes, especially a loaded vehicle.
It's ashame about the past and present emission laws, but then again, who wants acid rain.
I have done the sums on this. The 1GR-FE and the 1FD-FTV are about the same in running costs.
That is with fuel and maintenance. The 1GR-FE is cheaper to maintain, but more expensive on fuel, especially when it comes to touring. The 1KD-FTV is more expensive when it comes to maintenance, but cheaper on fuel.
What you do get for free with the 1KD-FTV, is a lot more low down torque, compared to the 1GR-FE (V6).
So if you can live with the noise, that's basically about it.
You could always install an insulator off a Prado 1KD-FTV. This should give you a bit of a sound barrier.
Yes, you do have to fit a catch can into the 1KD-FTVs. That has been built into the above example. If you fit a Mann Hummel Provent 200, you won't have to clean the EGR ever again, as you are taking out the binder, the oil residue.
You also have to check the sump screen on the 1KD-FTVs, but it's no biggy.
Yes, you can also say, Talktheroo is a diesel fitter, and he would say that, wouldn't he.
Well, I happen to love the 1GR-FEs, and they are a great engine, that's for sure, but I am a diesel man, and I happen to love the noise of them. That industrial noise, I happen to love, more than the smoothness of a V6.
Call me mad if you will, but that how it is for me.
The Roo.
I'd be keen on giving the insulator a try, drove from Sydney to Brisbane in my mates diesel Prado and I was amazed at how smooth and quiet the engine was compared to my Hilux.
Interested though in how you say the diesels about the same overall to run? Essentially both can be serviced at 10k intervals, and oil plus filters are pretty much the same going from petrol to diesel. IF you assume the injectors only last to around 200,000km (a good guestimate of how long they'd last), at a cost of around $1500 from Baileys then you can figure that costing you about an extra $75 per 10k service.
Now assuming the petrol engine uses, on average, about 3L more per 100km, then that adds up to around an extra $480 in fuel per 10k service.
Even if you throw a few more things at the diesel (fuel filter etc) you've still got a long way to go before evening up the running costs between the 2.