Page 1 of 3

POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Tue, 07 Oct 2008 10:15 +0000
by Dave
Hi everyone,

I have been asked a few times now if it was possible to consider allowing most of our forum categories (probably except for the trip section) publicly viewable (read-only) by guest users?

There are some pros and cons for this, here is some that come to mind:

Pros:
1) Google can index our site better, which will mean it'll be found much easier than before.
2) The general public will see what it's about prior to signing up to be able to post.
3) Hopefully new users will search for info first before they post up a question if it already exists.

Cons:
1) Lots of people will lurk the forums and not sign up at all, this will reduce the amount of new members coming on each day.
2) Your posts are viewable by anyone, anywhere without restriction, look at your photos, ideas etc. Which doesn't stop them if they sign up anyways.

I am very interested in your opinion so please cast your vote and possibly give me your feedback by responding to this thread.

This poll will run for 14 days from tonight..

Many thanks
Dave

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Wed, 08 Oct 2008 4:00 +0000
by cr1pp5
i dont think ya should make it public. If they join up yeah no worries, but as you said, you could get a lot of people just reading previous posts, but never actually sign up. As far as coverage goes, if i see another "new" hilux on the other forums, i let them know about this site. Also, i could make up some sort of flyer to give out to other hilux owners at shows/musters. I am sure we can get this site out to more hilux owners, we just need to know where to go.
Would it be possible to get advertising on 4x4 magazine web sites? I think that if we get the 'NewHilux.net' name out in the right spots, then we are guaranteed to get more members signing up.

Anyway, thats just my thoughts and ideas.

Cheers
John

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Wed, 08 Oct 2008 1:41 +0000
by Duges
G'day all,

I think it would be more encouraging for potential new members if they could have a look around first, much more generous and open. If they're decent types and have anything to contribute they'll want to become members after they see how much valuable information is available here.

Duges

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Wed, 08 Oct 2008 1:47 +0000
by cr1pp5
just scouted a new member from another forum. Told him about the site, and he said as soon as i mentioned tips and tricks, which includes ignition and seat belt beeper remover, he was in.

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Wed, 08 Oct 2008 1:56 +0000
by cr1pp5
keep an eye out for KWTRUK, he's the bloke i told about the site

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Wed, 08 Oct 2008 6:39 +0000
by Dave
cr1pp5 wrote:just scouted a new member from another forum. Told him about the site, and he said as soon as i mentioned tips and tricks, which includes ignition and seat belt beeper remover, he was in.


Good stuff mate, thanks!

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Thu, 09 Oct 2008 4:05 +0000
by bryhughes
Hi Dave and members,
I would support it as read only because once they have seen what is available on the site I believe they would be happy to join anyway. As read only it would keep out undesirable comments anyway.
Cheers

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Thu, 09 Oct 2008 8:32 +0000
by 4Hilux
Nah - make them join to read I reckon - theres a heap of inactive members already, that only come to browse etc. If it interests ya that much, you will join to see the whole lot.............

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Thu, 09 Oct 2008 9:06 +0000
by camwill69
Happy with read only.
Regards,
Camwill69

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Thu, 09 Oct 2008 9:21 +0000
by jamiecracker
[quote="camwill69"]Happy with read only.
Regards,
Camwill69[/quote]
works for me too

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Thu, 09 Oct 2008 9:34 +0000
by Shrek
Just an opinion here, I've been on a few other forums where you can see the original post on thread, but not the replies until you join. I think this would be a great way to entice/tease people. They'll see some of the content (plus google indexing).

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Fri, 10 Oct 2008 4:34 +0000
by Mark07SR5
I agree with shrek, then they get an idea of the content and if they want to know more they can join.

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Fri, 10 Oct 2008 5:08 +0000
by The Captain
Anyone who thinks that anything they do on the net is private is kidding themselves

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Fri, 10 Oct 2008 7:01 +0000
by Trini_hilux
I like shrek's idea...

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Sat, 11 Oct 2008 8:23 +0000
by cr1pp5
shrek's idea seems the best solution (if it is possible)

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Sat, 11 Oct 2008 9:21 +0000
by Dave
Hmm good one Shrek.. gives me something to think about - with a bit of customization that could be a possibility!

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Sat, 11 Oct 2008 10:53 +0000
by cr1pp5
I made up a quick flyer to hand out to fellow HiLux owners. What do you think? It looks like this, i just did it quickly in word, if you think it any good, i will do one properly in photshop.

You are invited to join

[img]http://www.newhilux.net/images/newhilux.jpg[/img]

Come and join our forum for free at http://www.newhilux.net
The site includes tips and tricks for your HiLux, Trips and events, General chat, Toyota news and much much more

Cheers
John

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Sat, 11 Oct 2008 3:11 +0000
by Hilux Max
in response to the three options I think by far the most important one is option 3 - I need more beer! :)

Other than that, I think that some things can be made public, like Off Topic and General Discussion area...but to get information like in Technical Section and to browse members profiles/shed and the classified section....I think you must become a member.

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Mon, 13 Oct 2008 7:14 +0000
by DLUX
if u want u can give some flyers to me, i work at TJM Megastore Coburg Melb.... Mon to wed.
i can put them on the fron counter. I get bout 5 to 6 hilux owners come in a day. up to you fellas.

Re: POLL: Do you think our threads & posts should be public?

PostPosted: Mon, 13 Oct 2008 10:27 +0000
by 9W6VX
dlux,

I think it's a great idea if your employer TJM Megastore does not mind.

Unfortunately though, I can't see the flyer that John aka cr1pp5 did. John, do you mind attaching the picture of the flyer for us to view?