Vks737 did a very interesting (and compelling) facebook post for using HF over a satphone.
When using HF, transmitting a message tho anyone listening on a emergency channel will be heard by others listening, who may be able to help;
Vks 737 facebook, 25-march
"SatPhones" thanks to
http://www.westprint.com.au• I was an Inmarsat Dealer for a fair while. The comments about pre-paid expiry are quite valid only lasting 30 days. However, if you do not activate them you have a 12-month shelf life on the prepaid vouchers and the 30 days only starts from when you activate it. I normally don't activate the voucher unless needed. OF UTMOST IMPORTANCE is the fact that you can dial 000 without having any credit or activated voucher. I believe that calls can also be received without credit. Peter.
• I read with interest the contributions about Satphone use, particularly when travelling remotely. While I do believe that satphones can be a useful tool to maintain contact when travelling this great country, I have some concerns about relying on them solely when in trouble. I have to confess at this point that I am a great supporter of HF radio, being a voluntary co-ordinator with VKS-737 Radio Network and also being the holder of an Advanced Amateur Radio Licence.
When in an emergency situation and asking for help via a satphone, who knows that you're in trouble? Your party and the person on the other end of the phone link. No one else because no one else can hear your conversation. All of the commercial HF Radio Providers have provision for people on their networks to gain help when things go badly downhill. On the network I represent (VKS-737 Radio Network), a four digit selcall gains help through any of our 19 base stations via a system that is monitored 24 hours a day, every day of the year. Another great advantage of requesting help via a HF radio is that assistance may actually not be that far away.
Last year, travellers on the Canning Stock Route had a rear suspension failure (broken U Bolts) north of Well 33. They called for assistance using their HF radio and within a short time, another traveller on our network passed them and gave them one of his spares. Additionally, another traveller at the Kunawarritji Community (Well 33) called on air to say he was parked in front of a wrecked Troop Carrier with the required U Bolts still on it. He made enquiries and secured both sets for a grand total of a $40 donation then delivered them to the stranded travellers; total cost equivalent to a few minutes of calls on a private satphone that no-one else would have heard.
Another example of the benefits of HF radio occurred when a club group had a major vehicle failure in the Victorian High Country. After repeated calls for assistance, using a satphone and expending over $50 of call costs, they still hadn't secured any assistance as they had trouble convincing the call takers in two states that they weren't in a built up area. One call on HF radio secured the required assistance and provided radio backup throughout their ordeal. A woman travelling solo in the New South Wales High Country became stranded early one evening. A call for help into our network got assistance on the way and also alerted other travellers close by who immediately came to her aid and secured her safety
What about the case of the two Korean cyclists on the Anne Beadell Highway who were ill equipped and ran out of food and water? The welfare calls over HF radio and the food and water drops saved their lives. Finally, the case of a New Zealand couple, experienced travellers in our outback who broke down on the Anne Beadell Highway at the WA Border with a transmission failure. They called on HF another traveller on our network heard their cry for help and detoured from north of Neale Junction to their spot and towed them into Ilkurlka Roadhouse, then subsequently assisted them all the way to Kalgoorlie. They are now lifelong friends. Try to achieve that via a satphone!
I haven't mentioned the many people who've become ill or have suffered accidents who've been helped successfully through the use of HF radio. Having only a satphone, you could travel within a short distance of someone in distress, possibly able to provide assistance but not even knowing that they were there.
Having a HF radio on board provides you with a community you wouldn't otherwise have. There are other people on your chosen network who you can talk with and even meet up with, gaining new friendships. You have ready access to weather information, particularly significant weather warnings. You can obtain information about road conditions and suggested camping spots from others who have a fair degree of experience. Most importantly, you have access to reliable help from people with local knowledge should things go pear shaped.
Yes, HF radios are expensive if purchased new. My pre-loved Barrett HF radio cost me $800, many years ago. Add a tapped whip for a couple of hundred and I had a system that could reliably talk across the country. I tell people that satphones have their place in maintaining contact with families and friends. Remember though that travellers can make phone calls using HF radio networks such as ours. UHF Citizens Band is good for point to point local comms, particularly in convoys. A HF radio will save your life if you're in the poop. I also strongly recommend an EPIRB for people who get off the well-travelled roads. Enjoy travelling but stay safe out there. Robert (VKS-737 Volunteer)